The Murder at Yellowstone City cast features Gabriel Byrne, Thomas Jane and Isaiah Mustafa. This info article contains minor spoilers and character details for Richard Gray’s 2022 movie on Netflix. Check out more cast guides in Vague Visages’ Know the Cast category.

Murder at Yellowstone City explores an Old West murder mystery. After a man strikes gold and suddenly dies, a former slave gets implicated as the killer. The narrative follows a sheriff and preacher as they search for the truth. Here’s every actor and character in Murder at Yellowstone City.

Read More at VV — Know the Cast: ‘Counterattack’

Murder at Yellowstone City Cast: Gabriel Byrne as Jim Ambrose

Character Profile: An Old West sheriff. He is a U.S. Army veteran who wants to bring hope back to his community. Sheriff Ambrose’s son gets implicated in a murder conspiracy.

Byrne’s Resume: Tom Reagan in Miller’s Crossing (1990), Keaton in The Usual Suspects (1995), The Man in End of Days (1999), Steve in Hereditary (2018), Bill Ward in War of the Worlds (2019-22)

Read More at VV — Know the Cast: ‘Havoc’

Murder at Yellowstone City Cast: Thomas Jane as Thaddeus Murphy

Character Profile: A preacher. He is a married man who worries about moral decline in his community. Thaddeus clashes with Sheriff Ambrose during a murder investigation.

Jane’s Resume: Todd Parker in Boogie Nights (1997), Pvt. Ash in The Thin Red Line (1998), Carter Blake in Deep Blue Sea (1999), David Drayton in The Mist (2007), Ted in Troppo (2022-24)

Read More at VV — Know the Cast: ‘Back in Action’

Murder at Yellowstone City Cast: Isaiah Mustafa as Cicero

Character Profile: A former slave. He raised himself as a child. Cicero gets accused of killing a gold prospector.

Mustafa’s Resume: Luke Garroway in Shadowhunters (2016-19), Mike Hanlon in It Chapter Two (2019), Porcupine Coach in Home Team (2022), Benny in Boy Kills World (2023), Detective John Sampson in Cross (2024)

Read More at VV — Know the Cast: ‘Ad Vitam’

Murder at Yellowstone City Cast: Anna Camp as Alice Murphy

Character Profile: Thaddeus’ wife. She is a religious woman with good morals. Alice defends her community from outlaws.

Camp’s Resume: Sarah Newlin in True Blood (2009-14), Jolene French in The Help (2011), Gwen Grandy in The Mindy Project (2012-13), Aubrey in Pitch Perfect (2012), Tracy Whitehead in Hysteria! (2024)

Read More at VV — Know the Cast: ‘Carry-On’

Murder at Yellowstone City Cast: Nat Wolff as Jimmy Ambrose Jr.

Character Profile: Sheriff Ambrose’s son. He is a local troublemaker. Jimmy gets involved in a murder conspiracy.

Wolff’s Resume: Fred in Palo Alto (2013), Quentin in Paper Towns (2015), Andrew Briggman in The Kill Team (2019), Lloyd Henreid in The Stand (2020-21), Craig Horne in The Consultant (2023)

Read More at VV — Know the Cast: ‘Emilia Pérez’

The Murder at Yellowstone City cast also includes:

• Richard Dreyfuss as Edgar Blake
• Scottie Thompson as Emma Dunnigan
• Aimee Garcia as Isabel Santos
• Tanaya Beatty as Violet Running Horse
• Zach McGowan as Robert Dunnigan
• John Ales as Mickey O’Hare
• Lew Temple as David Harding
• Danny Bohnen as Marcus O’Sullivan
• Isabella Ruby as Josephine Wright
• Lia Marie Johnson as Eugenia Martin
• Emma Kenney as Rebecca Davies
• Scotty Bohnen as Edwin Wilcox

Q.V. Hough (@QVHough) is Vague Visages’ founding editor.